← All Utah categories

Top 100 Insurance Companies in Utah — Graded

293 insurance companies in Utah clear our data floor — verified in at least two independent sources with a working phone or website — and are graded by one published formula. The top 100 are below; the full ranked list is split by metro area. Grades refreshed monthly; data current as of 2026-10-28.

Cedar City & Iron County (4)Logan & Cache Valley (14)Rest of Utah (28)Salt Lake Valley (174)St. George Area (17)Utah County (55)Lee's Summit (1)
1
99
Beehive Insurance
Salt Lake City · Website
Legitimacy100
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
2
99
Northern Title Company
Logan · Website
Legitimacy97
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
3
99
Blue Mountain Insurance
Provo · Website
Legitimacy100
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
4
99
Emi Health
Murray · Website
Legitimacy100
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
5
99
Health Plan Assistants St. George
St George · Website
Legitimacy100
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
6
99
The Bullock Agency
Logan · Website
Legitimacy97
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
7
99
WCF Insurance
Sandy · Website
Legitimacy97
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
8
98
The Buckner Company
Salt Lake City · Website
Legitimacy100
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
9
98
American Family Insurance
Riverdale · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
10
98
Ark Insurance Solutions
Salt Lake City · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
11
98
CBI Insurance Agency
Eden · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
12
98
Charger Title Insurance Agency
Orem · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
13
98
Cox Insurance Agency
American Fork · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
14
98
Easy Shop Insurance
Hurricane · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
15
98
Garner Insurance Concepts
Bountiful · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
16
98
Jay Carnahan - State Farm Insurance Agent
Ogden · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
17
98
JD Parry Insurance Agency
Ogden · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
18
98
L.A. Bowen Insurance Agency
Orem · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
19
98
Moreton & Company
Salt Lake City · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
20
98
Neal Dastrup Insurance
Provo · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
21
98
Security Insurance of Payson
Payson · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
22
98
Shumway Insurance Group
American Fork · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
23
98
The Center For Senior Benefits
Salt Lake City · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
24
98
Winward Financial Insurance & Investments LLC
Wellsville · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
25
97
Bahr Dermatology
Bountiful · Website
Legitimacy100
Online action94
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
26
97
Blackburn Jones Company
Ogden · Website
Legitimacy97
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
27
97
Joseph E Hansen Insurance
St George · Website
Legitimacy97
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
28
97
Protective Insurance Agency
Logan · Website
Legitimacy97
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
29
97
Adult Case Management
Spanish Fork · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
30
97
ASA Insurance
South Salt Lake · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
31
97
Beacon Financial LLC
Woods Cross · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
32
97
Central Utah Insurance Agency LLC
Moab · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
33
97
Charles James Cayias Insurance
Salt Lake City · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
34
97
Cutler Insurance Center
Draper · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
35
97
Dave Hardman State Farm Insurance Agent
Riverdale · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
36
97
Eastern Utah Insurance
Vernal · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
37
97
Emery Insurance Group
Sandy · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
38
97
Farm Bureau Financial Services
Cedar City · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
39
97
First American Title Insurance Company
St George · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
40
97
Four Seasons Insurance Agency, Inc.
West Jordan · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
41
97
Hatch Insurance Group
Draper · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
42
97
Healthy Horizon Insurance Agency
Bountiful · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
43
97
Heiner's Insurance Center
Ogden · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
44
97
Inside Insurance
American Fork · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
45
97
Insur-West
Farmington · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
46
97
Jed Miner & Associates Insurance Services, INC
Orem · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
47
97
Joe Andrus - State Farm Insurance Agent
Washington · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
48
97
Legacy Insurance and Financial Services
West Jordan · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
49
97
Lincoln Insurance Group
Sandy · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
50
97
Main Street Insurance Agency
Grantsville · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
51
97
Maple Mountain Insurance Services
Mapleton · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
52
97
Mindy Olsen Insurance Agency Inc - Logan Office - American Family Insurance
Logan · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
53
97
Mountain Ridge Insurance Group
Layton · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
54
97
Neal Dastrup Insurance
Spanish Fork · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
55
97
One Stop Insurance
West Jordan · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
56
97
Robert Pico
Murray · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
57
97
State Farm
Riverton · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
58
97
Stratford Insurance Group
Layton · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action100
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
59
95
Action Commercial Insurance Agency
Orem · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action94
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
60
95
Advance Insurance
Orem · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
61
95
Anderson Insurance Group
Taylorsville · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
62
95
Axis Insurance Agency
South Jordan · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action94
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
63
95
Berglund Insurance
Lehi · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
64
95
Bryan Insurance
Tooele · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action94
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
65
95
Compass Insurance Advisors
Draper · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
66
95
Cory J Chase Insurance Agency
Ogden · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
67
95
Craig Baugh - State Farm Insurance
Provo · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
68
95
Farmers Insurance
West Jordan · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action94
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
69
95
Guardian Ridge Insurance
South Salt Lake · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
70
95
Gwen King Insurance
Nibley · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action94
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
71
95
Healthcare Depot of Utah
Sandy · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
72
95
Hewlett Life and Health Insurance
Heber City · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
73
95
Hill Insurance
Salt Lake City · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action94
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
74
95
Lender Insurance
Orem · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
75
95
University of Utah Health Plans
Murray · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
76
95
Veracity Insurance Solutions
Pleasant Grove · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
77
94
Vantage Insurance Brokers
Spanish Fork · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action94
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
78
93
Benchmark Insurance Agency
Bountiful · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action90
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
79
93
Cornerstone Insurance Agency
Ogden · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action90
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
80
93
Utah Avenue Insurance
Payson · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action90
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
81
91
Desert Crest Insurance
St. George · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action90
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
82
91
Energy Insurance and Bonds
Bountiful · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action90
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
83
91
Farm Bureau Financial Services
Logan · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action87
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
84
91
Latino Insurance Services
Salt Lake City · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action90
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
85
91
Ponce de Leon Insurance
Taylorsville · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action90
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
86
91
Salmon Insurance LLC
Orem · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action90
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
87
91
SentryWest Insurance Services
Salt Lake City · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action87
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
88
91
Utah Association of Independent Insurance Agents
Salt Lake City · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action87
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
89
90
Cache Valley Insurance
Logan · Website
Legitimacy97
Online action84
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
90
90
Insure Right Insurance Agency
American Fork · Website
Legitimacy97
Online action85
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
91
90
Colleen Kelley
Sandy · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action87
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
92
90
Farm Bureau Financial Services
Tooele · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action85
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
93
90
Farm Bureau Financial Services
North Ogden · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action87
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
94
90
Morgan, Farm Bureau Financial Services
Morgan · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action85
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
95
90
Valley Insurance & Financial Services
Taylorsville · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action85
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
96
89
Ace Insurance
Riverton · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action84
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
97
88
AAA Farmington Branch
Farmington · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action85
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
98
88
Allstate
Farmington · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action85
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
99
88
Chris Lunt - American Affordable Insurance
Cedar City · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action82
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking
100
88
H&R Block
Heber City · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action85
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-28
Claim this ranking

See every graded insurance company: Cedar City & Iron County · Logan & Cache Valley · Rest of Utah · Salt Lake Valley · St. George Area · Utah County · Lee's Summit

How the AI Score works

Every company carries an AI Score from 1–100, computed by one published formula from the signals measurable today — legitimacy and online action, verified across at least two independent sources (open place datasets and public registries). The formula's other factors — blended reviews, complaint record, and responsiveness — carry no weight in the score until licensed data sources for them exist. When they land, the score re-spreads across the full formula.

One disclosed exception: a score of 100 is reserved for RankMyCompany clients; every other score is computed by the same formula for everyone. Scores are not spread artificially — companies with identical measured data share identical scores — and each listing also shows its rank and its percentile within its category.

Missing-data rule: when a factor has no lawful data source for a company yet, its weight redistributes proportionally across the factors that do have data, and every score shows its data-coverage %. Coverage rises as licensed sources are added; scores are recomputed monthly and score history is kept for every company.

No score is ever adjusted by hand, sold, or removed for payment. Companies marked RMC Client are scored by the exact same formula as everyone else — the 100 cap above is the only exception, and it is disclosed here rather than hidden. If your company's underlying data is wrong, file a correction on the dispute page — disputes fix the data, and the corrected data flows into the next ranking run.

Place data: © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL) and Overture Maps Foundation (CDLA Permissive 2.0). Listings are refreshed monthly; a score change from a refresh takes effect only after the new score holds for two consecutive runs. Formula changes are published as a new methodology version — never applied silently.

Read the full standard — The RMC Standard →